For last week’s class, we went on a field trip to Claflin Bakery and learned about the science of baking. We baked red velvet cupcakes with different variables applied for the amounts of baking soda. Among many topics that Lori discussed, I found the history of red velvet cupcakes interesting. I always thought of red velvet cupcakes as a gimmick with only its color modified from chocolate cake. Of course, the red color of the cake wasn’t originally from the dye. So, I decided to look into the source of redness that gave red velvet cupcakes its name.
The acidity of buttermilk and vinegar reacts with basic baking soda to fluff up the cake with CO2 air bubbles, giving it a nice and smooth velvety texture. In this process, the vinegar and buttermilk also reacted with cocoa that traditionally contain anthocyanins, which are antioxidants also found in red cabbages, pomegranate, and many other species. Anthocyanins react with both acid and base and give distinct color changes according to the different amounts of [H+]. When they react with acid, they turn red, and they react with base, they turn more brown. So, it was possible to get the red color just by adding vinegar and buttermilk with cocoa and flour, and it’s still possible to avoid using food coloring if we can get pure cocoa. However, today, most cocoa powder is processed with alkalizing agent, a base. So, traditional coca has a pH ~5 and base-processed cocoa powder has a pH ~7-8. Therefore, with the shifted pH range of color change in processed cocoa powder, it is hard to get the bright red color, making the food dye necessary.
I think that this science behind red velvet cupcake’s color is related to our results from the chemical leavener experiment. For the cake with no baking soda, we saw that it had a bright, highlight red color when we had put in equal drops of food coloring dye. This was probably because the acids (vinegar and buttermilk) that should act with the base (baking soda) to act as a leavener and create air bubbles in the normal recipe does not have the basic compounds to react with in the no BS sample. Instead, the acid reacts mostly with the cocoa powder to reach the pH for color change in the processed cocoa powder, and give a more red color than other samples. So, at the cost of having a dense and uncooked interior of the cake, we were able to get a bright and pretty color on the outside.